Islamabad (Pakistan News) – Minister of State for Interior Talal Chaudhry has criticised Pakistan Peoples Party Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari, saying that he presents himself as a strong advocate of the Constitution and democracy, but his performance regarding the Constitution is zero. He questioned why Maulana Fazlur Rehman should not be asked questions if questions can be raised about Hazrat Umar (RA).
Addressing a press conference, Talal Chaudhry was responding to Bilawal Bhutto’s recent statement. He said Bilawal had adopted a strong political position the previous day, but when it came to the Constitution, he only knew how to make ideological statements and had no practical performance to show.
He said there was no constitutional principle that allowed someone to declare certain articles correct simply because they liked them while rejecting the rest as wrong. The PPP governs three provinces, and the heads of those provinces also belong to the party. Despite this, he said, the party makes statements as though it has no connection with the government.
Talal Chaudhry said the PPP governs 70 per cent of the country. He added that the party also supports the creation of administrative units, but its position gives the impression that changes should not be made where governance is poor, while changes are being proposed even in areas where administration is comparatively better. He said the demand for new administrative units indicates that public services are not reaching ordinary citizens.
He said the PPP voted in favour of administrative units but later maintained that the decision had been taken under pressure. Bilawal had described the establishment of a constitutional court in the assembly as a need of the time and had also referred to speeches by Benazir Bhutto. However, the party was now portraying its vote as the result of coercion.
The minister of state questioned the logic of keeping authority under one's control if the intention was also to retain resources. Bilawal had spoken about bloodshed in the streets of Sindh, but, Talal Chaudhry asked, did voting lead to bloodshed or prevent it? He alleged that the PPP's 17 years of rule had severely affected the people of Sindh and said it should first be determined whether the people of the province had any blood left in their bodies.
Talal Chaudhry said Bilawal accepted only half of the Constitution and objected to the other half of the very Constitution created by his own party, despite the fact that government performance was also important in a democracy. According to him, constitutional amendments have historically been introduced in response to changing circumstances and public needs to improve people's lives.
Responding to Bilawal's remarks about shame and decency, he said Bilawal should direct those words towards his own governor, as Maulana Fazlur Rehman had first been criticised by a governor belonging to the PPP. Talal Chaudhry questioned whether Bilawal wanted to lecture his own governor on shame and decency. He said questions had been raised about Maulana Fazlur Rehman's assets and those of his sons, and that he should answer them.
The minister of state said that a long-term alliance had been formed when the present government came into power and that it was not intended to last for just one day. He said Bilawal wanted to deliver speeches and assume the role of the opposition, but there would be no change in the existing political arrangement.
Speaking about the PTI founder, Talal Chaudhry said he was being described as a political prisoner. However, he questioned what distinction remained between spreading chaos and engaging in activities against the state if the alleged mastermind of the May 9 incidents and the cases referred to as 190 was called a political prisoner.
He said that over the past few days, various video blogs had carried claims about the restoration of meetings with the PTI founder, his possible relief and his transfer from Adiala Jail to another location. At different times, reports had suggested that he might be moved to a hospital, Bani Gala or Nathia Gali. However, he said, all these claims were baseless. According to him, the PTI founder would remain where he was currently being held, and claims made in video blogs would not change the ground realities.
Talal Chaudhry further said that while criticising the government, the PPP should also take into account its own position in government and its responsibilities. He pointed out that PPP representatives held important constitutional offices, including the president and chairman of the Senate, while the party also governed three provinces.
He stressed that issues concerning the provinces should be resolved through mutual consultation and consensus rather than political confrontation. All parties, he said, should sit together to resolve their differences and work towards greater political harmony.